The Kidwelly Ghost
Press sources for a poltergeist that haunted a Kidwelly house in 1917:
Welshman, 26th January 1917:
KIDWELLY GHOST STORY. A "HAUNTED HOUSE."
Our correspondent writes:- Public interest in the "haunted house" at the Gasworks has grown very large during the last ten days or so. The house is a new one, only erected a couple of months ago for the convenience of the Manager, in order that he might be right on the spot. It is on the grounds of the Gasworks and is occupied by Mr. Ripper, the manager, his wife and four young children.
A fortnight or so ago uncanny noises began to be heard in the house by the occupants, in the way of incessant knocks or thuds. These invariably started about 8 o'clock every evening and continued till nearly midnight. During the past week or more a number of visitors have been attracted to the house to hear the mysterious noises, and on Friday evening of last week the visitors included the Vicar (Rev. D. Ambrose Jones), Rev. E. J. Herbert, C.M. Smart, Mr. Thomas (stationmaster), Mr. Sheppard, Mr. Davies (London House), and others.
Some of these tried to get into communication with the "ghost." and met with considerable success in this way, their knockings were responded to be the "sprite", and a code of signals arranged. A single knock signifies "Yes," silence "No," and numbers of knocks to denote weeks, days and numbers. First of all the ghost was asked how many people were present in the room that time. The reply was immediately forthcoming, seventeen knocks being given. On counting those present it was found that there were seventeen persons in the room and no more.
It was next asked how many of those present were known to "the presence." Six knocks were given in reply. Each person present was next presented singly and six were again recognised, those not known being treated with silence, if not contempt.
About six Weeks ago a young man, a shunter, on the G.W.R., was killed on the line not far from this spot and some people will say that it is the spirit of this young man who haunts the place, and indeed it is said that the noise or knocks have confirmed this, but why he makes his presence felt here is not known. Mr. Thomas, the stationmaster, vouches as to the truth of the knocks given answering in the affirmative the question as to the personality as above mentioned.
Mr. Rippen and his family, though not at all frightened, are greatly put out by the uncanny noises. Often, it is said, that when they sit alone together in a room the knocks come. They take no notice of them for a time, but they become so insistent that they at last knock in reply and afterwards all is still. There are also many other visitors who have tried to communicate with the author of these mysterious knocks, but it is only a few that are successful.
On January 27th the South Wales Weekly Post reported:
"GHOST" AT KIDWELLY. MYSTERIOUS "RAPPINGS" IN HOUSE.
Some uncanny stories are being told at the ancient Carmarthenshire borough of Kidwelly in respect of a dwelling house, where mysterious knockings are alleged to be heard every night. The Kidwelly case is quite out of the ordinary run of tappings, as the "knocker" is credited with a singular degree of intelligence, and readily responds to efforts to carry on "knock" conversations with his visitors.
A Press correspondent states that the strange noises were first heard three weeks ago, and for some time they were ignored by the occupants. Then the knockings became insistent, and the head of the house had to respond with reply knocks, and thereupon things quieted down. The noise starts almost every evening at 8 o'clock and finishes at 11.50. The place is visited nightly by many residents, including some of the most prominent inhabitants of the town. Some of these have tried to get into communication with the author of the thuds, and met with considerable success.
Code of Thuds was arranged - a single knock to denote "Yes," silence "No," and a series of knocks, numbers. By means of this code questions have been put and answered quite correctly. For instance, "his ghostliness"' was asked how many persons were then present, and immediately 17 knocks were heard. Seventeen persons were found to be present. A thorough search has been made for the cause, or causes, but without success, and several of the hitherto most sceptical persons now believe that the thuds are made by supernatural hands, and that someone dead wishes to convey a message to the living.
Llais Llafur, January 27th:
Kidwelly Mystery. UNCANNY INCIDENTS IN A HOUSE.
For the timebeing the war as the chief topic of conversation in the cattle trough of Kidwelly has had to give place in popular interest to a series of mysterious happenings in a recently erected house adjacent to the gas works, says a "Western Mail" correspondent. It was built for the convenience of the manager and is occupied by that official, Mr Rippen, and his wife. About a fortnight ago Mr Rippen's interest was aroused by a series of uncanny knocks, or thuds, caused apparently within the house, but whether directed against the wall or the ceiling or the floor he was unable to tell. The knocking continued for some time, and only ceased just before midnight.
On the following evening the same performance was repeated, much to the consternation of the occupants. Next day Mr Rippen mentioned the matter to some of his friends at Kidwelly, and they arranged to come over to the house in the evening to discover, if possible, the cause of this nocturnal demonstration. Soon after jiinc o'clock, when several persons were assembled in the room, the thuds began to be heard again. A complete search of the house was then made, with every room being carefully examined, as well as the ground around, but northinig was discovered to account for the noises.
A BAFFLING MYSTERY. Mr Rippen, who is a practical, level headed business man, told the "Western Mail" representative that these occurrences are to him a baffling mys-tery. "I am not a psychical research man in any way," he said, "and I have never before had any experiences of this kind which could not be explained, but this is quite beyond me, and I cannot fathotm it."
A remarkable story in confirmation pf the statement of Mr Rippen was made to the newspaper representative by a well-known resident, who fills a responsible position in the borough. "At the invitation of Mr Rippen," he said, "we arranged to go to his house a few nights ago. Several other friends were also present —in fact, we were a company of seven all told. At about. 9.30 p.m. the knockings (about which, I may say, I was sceptical) began. There could be no mistake about them. They were loud and distinct, and everyone in the room heard them. The sound, was a sort of muffled thud, and was repeated regularly."
TALKING TO THE UNKNOWN. We then began to ask questions, but there was no voice in response, only a continuation of the thuds. After that one of us asked, "How many people are there in this room at present?" In reply there came seventeen distinct thuds. "How many of the seventeen do you know?" was the next question. Six distinct thuds came in response. "What is your name?" we asked. No reply. We then informed the mysterious "knocker" that we would take one thud to mean a reply in the affirmative and we proceeded with our questions.
"Is your name Jones?" Silence. "Is it Thomas ?" Silence. "Is it Morris?" Silence. "Is it-- ?" One thud. I do not care to publish the name which elicited this affirmative thud, as it might be connected with something that happened in Kidwelly not so long ago, but everyone present will confirm this description of what happened. I could say more, but, perhaps, I had better not. I came away feeling as I never did before the truth of Hamlet's dictum—There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in our philosophy."
POLICE ON THE SCENE. On Monday night another group of prominent townsmen, visited the nouse. The company on this occasion included two police officers, one of whom stationed himself outside the promises, while his colleague was in the room. As on the previous evenings the mysterious noises were repeated, and the "ghost" answered a number of question fey means of the same "code." "It would be a good thing," said one of those present, "if a member of the Psychical Research Society came to Kidwelly to investigate this extraordinary mystery.
3rd February 1917, Llanelli Star:
The Kidwelly Ghost. ANOTHER "DEMONSTRATION" LAST NIGHT.
The series of remarkable occurrences at the house of the Kidwelly Gas Manager came to a sudden stop early this week, but last night they were resumed with added distinctness, much to the bewilderment of several gentlemen who had assembled. About nine o'clock the mysterious knockings began to be heard as before, and by means of the arranged code, questions were put and answered by the unknown visitant.
Among those present was a pronounced sceptic, who has all along maintained that the whole thing is a hoax engineered by some clever people to fool the public. So impressed was he last night, however, that he confessed that he had been profoundly mistaken, and like Hamlet he now declares, that there are more things in heaven and earth than are dreamt of in our philosophy.
The suggestion is made in some quarters that the knocks are nothing more nor less than noises caused in the gas pipes connected with the works which are close by. Tests have been made, however which dispose of this suggestion. An account of what has happened has been sent to Sir Oliver Lodge, who, it was hoped, would be able to come down and investigate the matter for himself. The eminent scientist has replied that it is impossible for him to visit Kidwelly at present, and he suggests that the code should be amplified so that other and more difficult questions may be put to the "ghost."
Llais Llafur reported on February 10th 1917:
The Kidwelly Ghost - MANIFESTATIONS AGAIN EXPERIENCED
The mysterious knocking or thudding at the Kidwelly gas manager's house still continues at intervals, though for a week or so past everything has been very quiet. The noises now come almost every other evening, and are of the character already referred to. The house is a new one, and has only been occupied for some four months. It is built of brick-hollow work, is on the ground, and quite adjoining the gas-works. There are railways on on two sides of it, a large engine-shed belonging to the Mynydd- garreg Kallway Company being near. We mention this, as it is reported by some workmen who are on duty late at night and early in the morning that they have heard similar knockings at the shed.
The whole affair, however, is of a most mysterious character, and quite unsolvable by ordinary methods. Sir Oliver Lodge, the great believer in spirit manifestations, has been communicated with, but he has not replied himself. The letters were handed over to his friend and fellow-student. plied himself. The letters were handed over to his friend and fellow-student, Mr J Arthur Hill, of Bradford, authorof "New Evidences in Psychical Research." and he writes saying that heis unable to give much advice, as so little is yet known of these things, but suggests an alphabetical code for communication with the author of the knockings. This, we understand, is now being tried with some success.
It is expected that a noted "spiritualist" or medium, will be down in Kidwelly in a day or two, and his or her experiments in the matter are looked forward to with considerable interest. Of those persons who have experienced and heard the rappings, or knocking there are quite many, and these thoroughly believe that a ghost or spirit is endeavouring to deliver some message or other; but the natural query is: "Why was this house, with its strange inmates, chosen for the reception?"' Mr Ripper and his family аre perfect strangers at Kidwelly, having only arrived there from England a few months ago.
The house was built in the position indicated owing to the fact that certain processes of the manufacture of gas and its components have to be watched at frequent intervals.
REMARKABLE COMMMUNCATIONS.
Parties stil continue to visit the house, but now the knocking is not always in evidence at stated hours, as before. For instance, a few evenings ago a party waited until after eleven o'clock, and nothing was heard, but almost immediately afterwards the knockings commenced, and the local police officer who had stayed behind with a friend had the full benefit of the manifestations.
The officer put several questions, speaking in his natural tone, and knockings were instantly given in reply.
The Officer: Do you know me? If so, give two knocks.
Two knocks were immediately forthcoming.
"Is my name Jones?" -Silence.
"Thomas?" -Silence.
"Williams?" -Silence.
"Morris?" Knock, denoting "yes."
"How many children have I?" -Two knocks.
"What number is my house?" -Ten knocks.
Both answers were correctly given, and, what is rather strange, very few people know that the constable's house is No. 10. It is always known as "The Police-station."
The constable next asked: "How many days are there in this month?" Twenty-eight knocks were immediately given.
It is also stated that by means of the alphabetical code, arranged and spoken of above, a message reading "I wish my mother would come" was received.
The Welshman of Friday 16th February reported:
THE KIDWELLY GHOST. COMMUNICATION CODE TRIED.
The mysterious knocking or thudding at a Kidwelly dwelling house still continues at intervals, though for a week or so past everything has been very quiet says the S.W.D. News. The noises now come almost every other evening, and are of the same character as before reported.
Sir Oliver Lodge, the great believer in spirit manifestations, has been communicated with but he has not replied himself. The letters were handed over to his friend and fellow student, Mr. J. Arthur Hill, of Bradford, author of "New Evidences in Psychical Research," and he writes saying that he is unable to give much advice, as so little is yet known of these things, but suggests an alphabetical code for communication with the author of the knockings. This, it is understood, is now being tried with some success.
It is expected that a noted spiritualist or medium will be down in Kidwelly in a day or two, and his or her experiments in the matter are looked forward to with considerable interest.
Of those persons who have experienced and heard the rappings or knocking, there are quite a number, and they include intelligent and educated people, who thoroughly believe that a ghost or spirit is endeavouring to deliver some message. In a further communication a correspondent says the local police officer has put several questions to the ghost, and knockings were instantly given in reply.
The Officer: Do you know me? If so, give two knocks. Two knocks were immediately forthcoming.
Is my name Jones?-Silence.
Is my name Thomas?. -Silence.
Is my name Williams? - Silence.
Is my name Morris?-Knock denoting yes.
How many children have I? Two knocks.
What number is my house? Ten knocks.
The answers were correct.
The Cambria Daily Leader of Feb 17th reported:
THE KIDWELLY GHOST. Turned Furniture Remover.
Kidwelly "ghost" has become aggressive. To its former activities it has added the feat of furniture moving, making things unpleasant at the gas manager's house. It is stated that one night a chair and a dress basket were thrown across one of the bedrooms, and the premises have now been vacated for a full investigation.
February 17th, Herald of Wales and Monmouthshire Recorder:
FRIENDLY WITH THE POLICE
On Thursday night another large party visited the haunted Kidwelly dwelling house with a view to an interview with the "ghost." The party included the Mayor of Kidwelly, the M.O.H., and several other prominent citizens. It was some time before any response could be got from th spirit world, but responsive knockings, were at last heard. The doctor was one of the few of those successful in getting replies.
The most successful was P.C. Morris, who entered into conversation with the "sprite" and invited him to come nearer and knock louder, but this he refused to do. By means of an alphabetical code the "ghost" correctly spelt the constable's name and also said his profession was "P-O-L-I-C-E." In further replies to P.C. Morris, the "ghost" gave the correct number ot persons present, also the correct time. The were very faint, and soon after 10.30 they ceased altogether.
(This report also appeared in the Llanelli Star on February 10th.)
Also on February 17th the Llanelly Star reported:
Ghost and Medium. DEVELOPMENTS AT KIDWELLY.
(Special to the "Star.") There has been a remarkable development in connection with the mysterious happenings at the Kidwelly Gasworks. On Wednesday night a lady medium from the neighbourhood of Pontypridd, paid a special visit to Kidwelly, accompanied by three friends for the purpose of interviewing the "ghost." Upon arrival at Kidwelly the party got into communication with Sergt. Hodge Lewis, who arranged with the occupant of the house that they should be received there that night. Accordingly about 9 p.m. there was assembled in the sitting-room the medium and her friends and a number of well-known Kidwelly gentlemen. Immediately the party were seated the medium offered up prayer, after which a "circle" was formed with the medium sitting in the centre of it. A few minutes later the now familiar "rappings" were heard in the room apparently coming from above.
In a Trance. This manifestation had an extraordinary effect upon the medium who went off into a trance. By this time the lights had been lowered and the room was in a state of semi-darkness. The medium then began to speak with a peculiar accent which sounded strangely upon the ears of those present who had heard her speaking a few minutes previously in her ordinary tone of voice. It soon became apparent that the medium was proceeding to refer to a distressing fatal accident wich occurred on the railway close by a few months ago when a young railway employe was killed. Pointing to the police-sergeant who formed one of the circle, she said, in staccato sentences— "That man—go there-stoop down—say be be careful." This was understood by all to refer to the fact that the sergeant was summoned after the accident and superintended the arrangements for the removal of the body.
Then the medium pointed to another gentleman in the room, saying: "That man—pay him money—and he signed the paper." Next came from her a representation of a man walking and a description of the injuries sustained by the unfortunate victim which tallied exactly with what happened, her indication of injuries to the head and limbs being what actually were suffered.
The lady was then requested to ask the "spirit" if he had any message and why he came there. The medium replied that the question had been left too late and that another medium would have to be engaged to elicit the answer at a cost of £5. The curiosity of those present seemed to be considerably damped by this £ s. d. announcement, and shortly after the "circle" was broken up, without any further enlightenment. The medium announced to the company, however, that she was taking the "spirit" with her to her home at Pontypridd.
Buried Treasure. In order to make the story of the rappings complete, a "Star" representative yesterday made inquiries at Kidwelly and secured some further interesting particulars. It appears that a couple of weeks ago when the rappings were heard, conversation was opened between a well-known local gentleman and the 'spirit' by means of an alphabetical code. We give the result in the form of question and answer —
Are you there now? —Three knocks (Yes).
Have you a message to give us? —Three knocks.
Will you give it to us now? —Three knocks.
Please let us have it then? —Something I want to say. Money hidden from the office near by the gas works. In the middle of Williams' field, opposite the back garden £20.
On a subsequent evening the message about hidden money was again given, but this time the spot where the buried treasure lies was described as 8 yards from the gas holder. On a third occasion the place was stated to be 18 yards from the railings dividing the railway from the field. It may he well to state here that no digging operations have yet been undertaken, nor are they likely to be.
The Sergeant's Name. On another evening Sergt. Hodge Lewis figured in an interesting series of questions to the unseen knocker. The sergeant is well-known in Kidwelly and there was a representative gathering of the townspeople in the room with him. This was the dialogue that ensued:—
Do you know me? Three knocks.
How long have you known me?—Three knocks (years).
Can you give me my name? -Three knocks.
What is it? —Lewis.
I have another name by which I am better known. Can you give it to me? One knock (No).
Can you give me the name of the town that I came from to Kidwelly? —Three knocks.
What is it? —Pembroke.
Unfortunately it so happens that Sergt. Lewis came from Llanelly to Kidwelly and he has never been in Pembroke in his life. Later on in the same evening, the spirit was asked if it (or he?) could furnish the name of the manager of the works and his wife. This the knocker successfully accomplished even to the second Christian name of that official and of his lady.
Cigarettes. Dealing further with local names another incident may he mentioned. One evening the company present included a local commercial gentleman who has taken the greatest interest in these manifestations.
"Do you know the gentleman sitting next to me?" the spirit was asked. —Three knocks.
"What is his name?" -The correct name was given.
Do you remember taking messages to his house? —Three knocks.
Did he used to give you anything? Three knocks.
What did he give you? —Cigarettes spelt according to the arranged code— C-i-g-e-r-e-t t s.
How many did he give you on one occasion. Give me a knock for each cigarette? —Fifty knocks came in response.
As throwing light upon this dialogue, it should be explained that earlier in the evening the gentleman had stated in the presence of all, that he had given a box of 50 cigarettes to the messenger referred to. This statement was not true, but it was made with the object of testing the genuineness of the unseen answerer. "As a matter of fact," said the gentleman subsequently to his friends, "I never gave him a cigarette in my life."
February 23rd, Western Mail:
KIDWELLY 'GHOST' BECOMES AGGRESSIVE
The Kidwelly "ghost" has become aggressive. To its former activities it has added the feat of furniture moving, making things unpleasant at the gas manager's house. It is stated that one night a chair and a dress basket were thrown across one of the bedrooms, and the premises have now been vacated for a full investigation.
Aberdare Leader of February 24th 1917:
KIDWELLY GHOST LAID? PENRHIWCEIBER SPIRITUALISTS' CLAIM.
Some inhabitants of Penrhiwceiber, who are members of the Miskin Spiritualistic Society, visited Kidwelly Tuesday, the 13th inst., for the purpose of solving the ghost mystery. Their names are: Mr. and Mrs. Phillips, 2 Dillwyn Street, and Mr. and Mrs. Brabon, of 26 Dillwyn Street. They claim that they have effectually laid the ghost. They informed our Penrhiwceiber correspondent that they and seven prominent residents of Kidwelly assembled at the Gasworks house, which was "haunted." "We had just taken our seats," they added, "when our spirit friend started knocking." We may say that it is believed that it was the spirit of a working-man who was killed by an express on the line at Kidwelly some time ago.
Afterwards, the medium, Mrs. Brabon, allowed her spirit-guide to work, and for two hours was under cross-examination. The most important questions asked were:-
Can you tell me who is troubling this room? -Guide: Yes, I will show you. -Then the form of a man who was recognised by the assembly as the man who was killed by the express was shown.
If that is he tell me how he died? -Guide: By being killed.
Is there anyone in this room that knows this man? -Yes (pointing to the station- master), that gentleman used to pay him his wages.
It was alleged that further particulars were given which tallied with the facts of the accident in question, and were verified by the man who picked up the mutilated body on the line. —-At the close of the meeting Mr. Phillips asked all present if they were satisfied that it was the spirit of the man who was killed. They answered that all that the Guide had spoken was perfectly true, and they promised to take the spirit with them, so that it would not worry the house at the Gasworks any more.
So far no more knocking has been heard, it is said Mr. and Mrs. Brabon are prepared to answer any questions with regard to this report privately or publicly.
February 26th 1917, Cambria Daily Leader:
KIDWELLY SPOOK. SOME CURIOUS STORIES OF MESSAGES (By AWSTIN).
When you are in quest of "it," you should not be frivolous, and yet the heading of my previous article might have suggested to some that I was then writing in a very light mood. Fancy writing "ghosty" as an appellation for a spook. Now, that bit of flightineas must bo attributed to the "Printer's Devil," who (notwithstanding the introduction of type-setting machinery, still hovers around a printing office when the men are not in "chapel.") He must have been "it" in regard to that extra "y."
Among the curious stories I heard in confirmation and expansion of tho explanations given me by Mr. Rippin was one which showed that although the warning of the alleged spook on the question of vacating the house was not acted upon in ten days, no consequences followed but then, the warning was only a response to a question put, and the penalty (if any) was not mentioned. And the letter from Mr. J. Arthur Hill, on behalf of Sir Oliver Lodge, indicated that he does not think that such messages are always reliable. The period fixed has gone by, and nothing has happened!
On the other hand, communications with regard to distant friends (at the front) were correct, and further developments may yet bo anticipated in that, direction. The sequel does not depend upon the spook, but upon letters of friends. Stories of hidden money, and the possibility of search for it, must be taken with a grain of salt, as they do not emanate from the spook or the people in the house.
On the table in the middle of the room in which the taps are generally heard is a large family Bible, and, one night, a visitor placed his hand upon it. "It" was asked if it could see the gentleman. Three knocks came for yes. What has he got in his hand was next asked, and the answer was "a ring", but when further pressed about a book, the spirit, or whatever it is, replied, "The Holy Scriptures". On another occasion a new book on psychical subjects was held in the hand, and the presence gave the title of the book correctly. The stories are cited in support of the theory that "it" can not only hear what is said in the room, but see who and what is there.
Now, do not let us have any mistake about the character of these responses. They were not spoken in words. The spook's voice was not heard. The words were spelt out by the code referred to in Mr. Hill's letter." The person who asked the question would S: A," B," C," and follow on with the alphabet until he or she came to the right and proper one, when a tap from it would stop the querist going any further. And if an enthusiastic investigator proceeded with the alphabet too far, the spook would give several raps, or thumps, or dull thuds - you don't know exactly how to describe them and you don't know where they come from, whether from floor or ceiling or walls or furniture. When you have fixed one letter you begin on the alphabet again and go on until you get the second, and so on.
The story of the spoken voice is a separate one. When the ladv medium from Penrhiwceiber got into "control" of "it," some of the seekers after truth thought they might get her to elicit replies in good English or sound Welsh —in spoken words, so that they might hear the voice. The lady, however, explained that someone on a higher plane in the spirit world might be able to draw out the voice, but she could not. Now, as this is a story which has led to suggestions, among the gossips, of money transactions, it may be well to give the version of the incident which was related to me bv Mr. Rippin and absolutely confirmed by a gentleman who holds an important offical position in Kidwelly.
The lady medium said that she knew of a frignd who could probably do what was asked, but, as she was a professional, it would cost about £5 to get her to come. She did not advise getting her (as has been suggested), but in the peculiar intonation and "Mahatma"—like phrasing of one in a trance she defined her own limitations and seemingly the only way out of the difficulty, if such a solution was necessary. Nobody proposed spending £5 on the quest in that direction, and the matter dropped.
The quaint story of the cigarettes, take it any wy you like, is a decidedly funny one, but it requires telling carefully, as there are at least two versions of it. A well-known local man of business suggested that the "spook" might be asked if it remembered him giving "it," in its lifetime on earth, a box of 50 cigarettes. Mr. Rippin put the question, and the reply was "No." The "spirit" at what ever "it" is remembered tho gentleman very well, and could see him there, but it had not had 50 cigarettes from him —nor any cigarettes at all, in fact. No amount of pressure would get an admission from it," and at last Mr. Rippen gave up the attempt. Someone else in the room tried, and, after some fencing as to not remembering, the spirit admitted having had a parcel or packet, and it then misspelt the word cigarettes, fixing the number the packet contained at 50.
Mr. Rippin was very emphatic, in conversation with me, that he had not elicited that reply. It was brought out by another investigator, and as the gentleman who had desired the question to be put afterwards declared it was not true, as he had never given the original of the supposed spirit any cigarettes in his life, the incident has caused some unpleasantness in the little circle of inquirers, and investigators, owing mainly to the story having gone out in a form which seemed to suggest that Mr. Rippin got the spirit to tell a fib under pressure. But he did not.
And the answer to the success of such transparent traps, no doubt, would be the same as that of Mr. J. Arthur Hill (on the house vacating question): "I do not think such messages are always reliable." These stories, from grave to gay, from lively to serene, might be multiplied galore, but I think sufficient has been given to illustrate the character of the proceedings of spook and people at the Kidwelly haunted house. No solution of the mystery has yet been found, and the readiness and freedom with which those who have been present as watchers discuss "it" and its rapping have helped to make the Kidwelly "ghost" a household word in the town and for many, many miles around.
Not only have as many as 17 people been keenly watching together in one room, but small parties have sounded walls, floors, and ceilings, visited the children's bedrooms, and sometimes thought (wrongly, as it turned out) that they had discovered how the mystery was worked, but silent sentries, posted outside the house, in the gasworks yard, kept watch and ward, at the same time, lest confederates might be operating in the open air or from secret hidden places. However, there were no discoveries. There, for the present, I conclude my plain, unvarnished tale of the quest for "it" at Kidwelly. If there are further developments there may be something more to say—later on.
On March 2nd, the Carmarthen Journal reported:
THE KIDWELLY GHOST. The knockings of the Kidwelly ghost are getting louder, and the "spirit" has added to its achievements that of throwing the furniture about. On Wednesday night of last week a chair and a dress basket were hurled by some unseen force right across one of the bedrooms. On Friday night a small committee of investigators visited the house.
March 3rd 1917, Aberdare Leader:
Letters to the Editor. THE KIDWELLY GHOST. Re. the invitation to questions by Mr. and Mrs. Brabon concerning the report on the above subject, which appeared in your last issue, I should like to ask:- How do they explain the report that appeared in the press last Friday which says that the Kidwelly Ghost has become more aggressive than ever, making things unpleasant, and that it is still at the Gasworks House? Do they still maintain that they have removed the Ghost?
If so, was there any oversight or neglect on the part of the Ghost's custodians since they promised to take the Ghost with them? Now, with all the seriousness at my command, I beg to ask, Do they wilfully endeavour to deceive the public or are they themselves deceived? I am inclined to believe the latter, in which case they are more to be pitied than blamed.
—Yours, G. H. EVANS. 47 Dilwyn Street, Penrhiwceiber.
Aberdare Leader, March 10th 1917:
THE KIDWELLY GHOST.
Sir, Kindly allow me a small space in your paper to answer Mr. G. H. Evans's enquiries re the Kidwelly Ghost. Firstly, about the ghost becoming aggressive, I beg leave to contradict the statement appearing in the press. I have in my possession a letter from the tenant of tha haunted house to prove differently, and anyone calling at our house may see it. I think the lady is competent to judge.
Secondly, whether we maintain that we removed the ghost. We maintain that we proved to them who troubled the house, and that I would endeavour to help that friend to progress. Now to the third question, are we wilfully endeavouring to deceive the public or are we ourselves deceived? If so, I beg to say we are quite willing to be classed as lunatics in company with such highly scientific men as General Sir Alfred Turner, Sir Oliver Lodge, Sir Wm. Crookes, Stainton Moses, and others who firmly believe in the continuity of life and the power of communication with beings who have passed the border. And, Mr. Editor, I don't think we need the pity G. H. Evans expresses, because ordinary minds usually condemn everything that is beyond their scope of understanding.
We remain, T. & A. BRABON. 26 Dilwyn Street, Penrhiwceiber.
The last newspaper hit I found was from the Aberdare Leader of March 17th:
THE KIDWELLY GHOST. In your last issue there was a letter signed "T. and A. Brabon," upon the above subject, claiming to answer my query. If they were responsible for the letter that appeared as challenge they must know that the two statements are conflicting.
In that letter it says that they promised to take the ghost with them. In the last letter they say "that they proved who troubled the house." Between these there exists a vast difference. They further claim that the house is not still haunted. There appeared in the press several days after their departure from Kidwelly reports that it was still troubling. Why not refuse the press statements then, not now? Can they suggest why was a patrol placed around the house after they had claimed to have removed the ghost?
In the account of their visit we find that a certain Mr. Rippin put a question concerning a packet of 50 cigarettes. The ghost could not remember receiving any cigarettes from Mr. Rippin. Another again put the same question, and the answer came yes. Now, Mr. Rippin says he never did give the ghost any cigarettes. Now, an ordinary mind knows that what is contrary to the truth must be a lie.
They say they are willing to be classed as lunatics in company with certain men. Anyone knowing the meaning of the word lunatic would not apply it in such a case. There is not much fear of lunatics deceiving anybody. Since these people claim the company of such noted men, will they also include the women clairvoyants in Newport and London who have been punished for their practices!
Speaking of "ordinary mind", there are two classes outside the ordinary mind, i.e., above and below, but the ordinary mind is the ballast in the mental world. The extraordinary minds are very liable to go astray. Concerning the pity, I admit they ought to know best whether they deserve it or not.
—I am, yours, etc, G. H. EVANS. 47 Dilwyn Street, Penrhiwceiber.
Welshman, 26th January 1917:
KIDWELLY GHOST STORY. A "HAUNTED HOUSE."
Our correspondent writes:- Public interest in the "haunted house" at the Gasworks has grown very large during the last ten days or so. The house is a new one, only erected a couple of months ago for the convenience of the Manager, in order that he might be right on the spot. It is on the grounds of the Gasworks and is occupied by Mr. Ripper, the manager, his wife and four young children.
A fortnight or so ago uncanny noises began to be heard in the house by the occupants, in the way of incessant knocks or thuds. These invariably started about 8 o'clock every evening and continued till nearly midnight. During the past week or more a number of visitors have been attracted to the house to hear the mysterious noises, and on Friday evening of last week the visitors included the Vicar (Rev. D. Ambrose Jones), Rev. E. J. Herbert, C.M. Smart, Mr. Thomas (stationmaster), Mr. Sheppard, Mr. Davies (London House), and others.
Some of these tried to get into communication with the "ghost." and met with considerable success in this way, their knockings were responded to be the "sprite", and a code of signals arranged. A single knock signifies "Yes," silence "No," and numbers of knocks to denote weeks, days and numbers. First of all the ghost was asked how many people were present in the room that time. The reply was immediately forthcoming, seventeen knocks being given. On counting those present it was found that there were seventeen persons in the room and no more.
It was next asked how many of those present were known to "the presence." Six knocks were given in reply. Each person present was next presented singly and six were again recognised, those not known being treated with silence, if not contempt.
About six Weeks ago a young man, a shunter, on the G.W.R., was killed on the line not far from this spot and some people will say that it is the spirit of this young man who haunts the place, and indeed it is said that the noise or knocks have confirmed this, but why he makes his presence felt here is not known. Mr. Thomas, the stationmaster, vouches as to the truth of the knocks given answering in the affirmative the question as to the personality as above mentioned.
Mr. Rippen and his family, though not at all frightened, are greatly put out by the uncanny noises. Often, it is said, that when they sit alone together in a room the knocks come. They take no notice of them for a time, but they become so insistent that they at last knock in reply and afterwards all is still. There are also many other visitors who have tried to communicate with the author of these mysterious knocks, but it is only a few that are successful.
On January 27th the South Wales Weekly Post reported:
"GHOST" AT KIDWELLY. MYSTERIOUS "RAPPINGS" IN HOUSE.
Some uncanny stories are being told at the ancient Carmarthenshire borough of Kidwelly in respect of a dwelling house, where mysterious knockings are alleged to be heard every night. The Kidwelly case is quite out of the ordinary run of tappings, as the "knocker" is credited with a singular degree of intelligence, and readily responds to efforts to carry on "knock" conversations with his visitors.
A Press correspondent states that the strange noises were first heard three weeks ago, and for some time they were ignored by the occupants. Then the knockings became insistent, and the head of the house had to respond with reply knocks, and thereupon things quieted down. The noise starts almost every evening at 8 o'clock and finishes at 11.50. The place is visited nightly by many residents, including some of the most prominent inhabitants of the town. Some of these have tried to get into communication with the author of the thuds, and met with considerable success.
Code of Thuds was arranged - a single knock to denote "Yes," silence "No," and a series of knocks, numbers. By means of this code questions have been put and answered quite correctly. For instance, "his ghostliness"' was asked how many persons were then present, and immediately 17 knocks were heard. Seventeen persons were found to be present. A thorough search has been made for the cause, or causes, but without success, and several of the hitherto most sceptical persons now believe that the thuds are made by supernatural hands, and that someone dead wishes to convey a message to the living.
Llais Llafur, January 27th:
Kidwelly Mystery. UNCANNY INCIDENTS IN A HOUSE.
For the timebeing the war as the chief topic of conversation in the cattle trough of Kidwelly has had to give place in popular interest to a series of mysterious happenings in a recently erected house adjacent to the gas works, says a "Western Mail" correspondent. It was built for the convenience of the manager and is occupied by that official, Mr Rippen, and his wife. About a fortnight ago Mr Rippen's interest was aroused by a series of uncanny knocks, or thuds, caused apparently within the house, but whether directed against the wall or the ceiling or the floor he was unable to tell. The knocking continued for some time, and only ceased just before midnight.
On the following evening the same performance was repeated, much to the consternation of the occupants. Next day Mr Rippen mentioned the matter to some of his friends at Kidwelly, and they arranged to come over to the house in the evening to discover, if possible, the cause of this nocturnal demonstration. Soon after jiinc o'clock, when several persons were assembled in the room, the thuds began to be heard again. A complete search of the house was then made, with every room being carefully examined, as well as the ground around, but northinig was discovered to account for the noises.
A BAFFLING MYSTERY. Mr Rippen, who is a practical, level headed business man, told the "Western Mail" representative that these occurrences are to him a baffling mys-tery. "I am not a psychical research man in any way," he said, "and I have never before had any experiences of this kind which could not be explained, but this is quite beyond me, and I cannot fathotm it."
A remarkable story in confirmation pf the statement of Mr Rippen was made to the newspaper representative by a well-known resident, who fills a responsible position in the borough. "At the invitation of Mr Rippen," he said, "we arranged to go to his house a few nights ago. Several other friends were also present —in fact, we were a company of seven all told. At about. 9.30 p.m. the knockings (about which, I may say, I was sceptical) began. There could be no mistake about them. They were loud and distinct, and everyone in the room heard them. The sound, was a sort of muffled thud, and was repeated regularly."
TALKING TO THE UNKNOWN. We then began to ask questions, but there was no voice in response, only a continuation of the thuds. After that one of us asked, "How many people are there in this room at present?" In reply there came seventeen distinct thuds. "How many of the seventeen do you know?" was the next question. Six distinct thuds came in response. "What is your name?" we asked. No reply. We then informed the mysterious "knocker" that we would take one thud to mean a reply in the affirmative and we proceeded with our questions.
"Is your name Jones?" Silence. "Is it Thomas ?" Silence. "Is it Morris?" Silence. "Is it-- ?" One thud. I do not care to publish the name which elicited this affirmative thud, as it might be connected with something that happened in Kidwelly not so long ago, but everyone present will confirm this description of what happened. I could say more, but, perhaps, I had better not. I came away feeling as I never did before the truth of Hamlet's dictum—There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in our philosophy."
POLICE ON THE SCENE. On Monday night another group of prominent townsmen, visited the nouse. The company on this occasion included two police officers, one of whom stationed himself outside the promises, while his colleague was in the room. As on the previous evenings the mysterious noises were repeated, and the "ghost" answered a number of question fey means of the same "code." "It would be a good thing," said one of those present, "if a member of the Psychical Research Society came to Kidwelly to investigate this extraordinary mystery.
3rd February 1917, Llanelli Star:
The Kidwelly Ghost. ANOTHER "DEMONSTRATION" LAST NIGHT.
The series of remarkable occurrences at the house of the Kidwelly Gas Manager came to a sudden stop early this week, but last night they were resumed with added distinctness, much to the bewilderment of several gentlemen who had assembled. About nine o'clock the mysterious knockings began to be heard as before, and by means of the arranged code, questions were put and answered by the unknown visitant.
Among those present was a pronounced sceptic, who has all along maintained that the whole thing is a hoax engineered by some clever people to fool the public. So impressed was he last night, however, that he confessed that he had been profoundly mistaken, and like Hamlet he now declares, that there are more things in heaven and earth than are dreamt of in our philosophy.
The suggestion is made in some quarters that the knocks are nothing more nor less than noises caused in the gas pipes connected with the works which are close by. Tests have been made, however which dispose of this suggestion. An account of what has happened has been sent to Sir Oliver Lodge, who, it was hoped, would be able to come down and investigate the matter for himself. The eminent scientist has replied that it is impossible for him to visit Kidwelly at present, and he suggests that the code should be amplified so that other and more difficult questions may be put to the "ghost."
Llais Llafur reported on February 10th 1917:
The Kidwelly Ghost - MANIFESTATIONS AGAIN EXPERIENCED
The mysterious knocking or thudding at the Kidwelly gas manager's house still continues at intervals, though for a week or so past everything has been very quiet. The noises now come almost every other evening, and are of the character already referred to. The house is a new one, and has only been occupied for some four months. It is built of brick-hollow work, is on the ground, and quite adjoining the gas-works. There are railways on on two sides of it, a large engine-shed belonging to the Mynydd- garreg Kallway Company being near. We mention this, as it is reported by some workmen who are on duty late at night and early in the morning that they have heard similar knockings at the shed.
The whole affair, however, is of a most mysterious character, and quite unsolvable by ordinary methods. Sir Oliver Lodge, the great believer in spirit manifestations, has been communicated with, but he has not replied himself. The letters were handed over to his friend and fellow-student. plied himself. The letters were handed over to his friend and fellow-student, Mr J Arthur Hill, of Bradford, authorof "New Evidences in Psychical Research." and he writes saying that heis unable to give much advice, as so little is yet known of these things, but suggests an alphabetical code for communication with the author of the knockings. This, we understand, is now being tried with some success.
It is expected that a noted "spiritualist" or medium, will be down in Kidwelly in a day or two, and his or her experiments in the matter are looked forward to with considerable interest. Of those persons who have experienced and heard the rappings, or knocking there are quite many, and these thoroughly believe that a ghost or spirit is endeavouring to deliver some message or other; but the natural query is: "Why was this house, with its strange inmates, chosen for the reception?"' Mr Ripper and his family аre perfect strangers at Kidwelly, having only arrived there from England a few months ago.
The house was built in the position indicated owing to the fact that certain processes of the manufacture of gas and its components have to be watched at frequent intervals.
REMARKABLE COMMMUNCATIONS.
Parties stil continue to visit the house, but now the knocking is not always in evidence at stated hours, as before. For instance, a few evenings ago a party waited until after eleven o'clock, and nothing was heard, but almost immediately afterwards the knockings commenced, and the local police officer who had stayed behind with a friend had the full benefit of the manifestations.
The officer put several questions, speaking in his natural tone, and knockings were instantly given in reply.
The Officer: Do you know me? If so, give two knocks.
Two knocks were immediately forthcoming.
"Is my name Jones?" -Silence.
"Thomas?" -Silence.
"Williams?" -Silence.
"Morris?" Knock, denoting "yes."
"How many children have I?" -Two knocks.
"What number is my house?" -Ten knocks.
Both answers were correctly given, and, what is rather strange, very few people know that the constable's house is No. 10. It is always known as "The Police-station."
The constable next asked: "How many days are there in this month?" Twenty-eight knocks were immediately given.
It is also stated that by means of the alphabetical code, arranged and spoken of above, a message reading "I wish my mother would come" was received.
The Welshman of Friday 16th February reported:
THE KIDWELLY GHOST. COMMUNICATION CODE TRIED.
The mysterious knocking or thudding at a Kidwelly dwelling house still continues at intervals, though for a week or so past everything has been very quiet says the S.W.D. News. The noises now come almost every other evening, and are of the same character as before reported.
Sir Oliver Lodge, the great believer in spirit manifestations, has been communicated with but he has not replied himself. The letters were handed over to his friend and fellow student, Mr. J. Arthur Hill, of Bradford, author of "New Evidences in Psychical Research," and he writes saying that he is unable to give much advice, as so little is yet known of these things, but suggests an alphabetical code for communication with the author of the knockings. This, it is understood, is now being tried with some success.
It is expected that a noted spiritualist or medium will be down in Kidwelly in a day or two, and his or her experiments in the matter are looked forward to with considerable interest.
Of those persons who have experienced and heard the rappings or knocking, there are quite a number, and they include intelligent and educated people, who thoroughly believe that a ghost or spirit is endeavouring to deliver some message. In a further communication a correspondent says the local police officer has put several questions to the ghost, and knockings were instantly given in reply.
The Officer: Do you know me? If so, give two knocks. Two knocks were immediately forthcoming.
Is my name Jones?-Silence.
Is my name Thomas?. -Silence.
Is my name Williams? - Silence.
Is my name Morris?-Knock denoting yes.
How many children have I? Two knocks.
What number is my house? Ten knocks.
The answers were correct.
The Cambria Daily Leader of Feb 17th reported:
THE KIDWELLY GHOST. Turned Furniture Remover.
Kidwelly "ghost" has become aggressive. To its former activities it has added the feat of furniture moving, making things unpleasant at the gas manager's house. It is stated that one night a chair and a dress basket were thrown across one of the bedrooms, and the premises have now been vacated for a full investigation.
February 17th, Herald of Wales and Monmouthshire Recorder:
FRIENDLY WITH THE POLICE
On Thursday night another large party visited the haunted Kidwelly dwelling house with a view to an interview with the "ghost." The party included the Mayor of Kidwelly, the M.O.H., and several other prominent citizens. It was some time before any response could be got from th spirit world, but responsive knockings, were at last heard. The doctor was one of the few of those successful in getting replies.
The most successful was P.C. Morris, who entered into conversation with the "sprite" and invited him to come nearer and knock louder, but this he refused to do. By means of an alphabetical code the "ghost" correctly spelt the constable's name and also said his profession was "P-O-L-I-C-E." In further replies to P.C. Morris, the "ghost" gave the correct number ot persons present, also the correct time. The were very faint, and soon after 10.30 they ceased altogether.
(This report also appeared in the Llanelli Star on February 10th.)
Also on February 17th the Llanelly Star reported:
Ghost and Medium. DEVELOPMENTS AT KIDWELLY.
(Special to the "Star.") There has been a remarkable development in connection with the mysterious happenings at the Kidwelly Gasworks. On Wednesday night a lady medium from the neighbourhood of Pontypridd, paid a special visit to Kidwelly, accompanied by three friends for the purpose of interviewing the "ghost." Upon arrival at Kidwelly the party got into communication with Sergt. Hodge Lewis, who arranged with the occupant of the house that they should be received there that night. Accordingly about 9 p.m. there was assembled in the sitting-room the medium and her friends and a number of well-known Kidwelly gentlemen. Immediately the party were seated the medium offered up prayer, after which a "circle" was formed with the medium sitting in the centre of it. A few minutes later the now familiar "rappings" were heard in the room apparently coming from above.
In a Trance. This manifestation had an extraordinary effect upon the medium who went off into a trance. By this time the lights had been lowered and the room was in a state of semi-darkness. The medium then began to speak with a peculiar accent which sounded strangely upon the ears of those present who had heard her speaking a few minutes previously in her ordinary tone of voice. It soon became apparent that the medium was proceeding to refer to a distressing fatal accident wich occurred on the railway close by a few months ago when a young railway employe was killed. Pointing to the police-sergeant who formed one of the circle, she said, in staccato sentences— "That man—go there-stoop down—say be be careful." This was understood by all to refer to the fact that the sergeant was summoned after the accident and superintended the arrangements for the removal of the body.
Then the medium pointed to another gentleman in the room, saying: "That man—pay him money—and he signed the paper." Next came from her a representation of a man walking and a description of the injuries sustained by the unfortunate victim which tallied exactly with what happened, her indication of injuries to the head and limbs being what actually were suffered.
The lady was then requested to ask the "spirit" if he had any message and why he came there. The medium replied that the question had been left too late and that another medium would have to be engaged to elicit the answer at a cost of £5. The curiosity of those present seemed to be considerably damped by this £ s. d. announcement, and shortly after the "circle" was broken up, without any further enlightenment. The medium announced to the company, however, that she was taking the "spirit" with her to her home at Pontypridd.
Buried Treasure. In order to make the story of the rappings complete, a "Star" representative yesterday made inquiries at Kidwelly and secured some further interesting particulars. It appears that a couple of weeks ago when the rappings were heard, conversation was opened between a well-known local gentleman and the 'spirit' by means of an alphabetical code. We give the result in the form of question and answer —
Are you there now? —Three knocks (Yes).
Have you a message to give us? —Three knocks.
Will you give it to us now? —Three knocks.
Please let us have it then? —Something I want to say. Money hidden from the office near by the gas works. In the middle of Williams' field, opposite the back garden £20.
On a subsequent evening the message about hidden money was again given, but this time the spot where the buried treasure lies was described as 8 yards from the gas holder. On a third occasion the place was stated to be 18 yards from the railings dividing the railway from the field. It may he well to state here that no digging operations have yet been undertaken, nor are they likely to be.
The Sergeant's Name. On another evening Sergt. Hodge Lewis figured in an interesting series of questions to the unseen knocker. The sergeant is well-known in Kidwelly and there was a representative gathering of the townspeople in the room with him. This was the dialogue that ensued:—
Do you know me? Three knocks.
How long have you known me?—Three knocks (years).
Can you give me my name? -Three knocks.
What is it? —Lewis.
I have another name by which I am better known. Can you give it to me? One knock (No).
Can you give me the name of the town that I came from to Kidwelly? —Three knocks.
What is it? —Pembroke.
Unfortunately it so happens that Sergt. Lewis came from Llanelly to Kidwelly and he has never been in Pembroke in his life. Later on in the same evening, the spirit was asked if it (or he?) could furnish the name of the manager of the works and his wife. This the knocker successfully accomplished even to the second Christian name of that official and of his lady.
Cigarettes. Dealing further with local names another incident may he mentioned. One evening the company present included a local commercial gentleman who has taken the greatest interest in these manifestations.
"Do you know the gentleman sitting next to me?" the spirit was asked. —Three knocks.
"What is his name?" -The correct name was given.
Do you remember taking messages to his house? —Three knocks.
Did he used to give you anything? Three knocks.
What did he give you? —Cigarettes spelt according to the arranged code— C-i-g-e-r-e-t t s.
How many did he give you on one occasion. Give me a knock for each cigarette? —Fifty knocks came in response.
As throwing light upon this dialogue, it should be explained that earlier in the evening the gentleman had stated in the presence of all, that he had given a box of 50 cigarettes to the messenger referred to. This statement was not true, but it was made with the object of testing the genuineness of the unseen answerer. "As a matter of fact," said the gentleman subsequently to his friends, "I never gave him a cigarette in my life."
February 23rd, Western Mail:
KIDWELLY 'GHOST' BECOMES AGGRESSIVE
The Kidwelly "ghost" has become aggressive. To its former activities it has added the feat of furniture moving, making things unpleasant at the gas manager's house. It is stated that one night a chair and a dress basket were thrown across one of the bedrooms, and the premises have now been vacated for a full investigation.
Aberdare Leader of February 24th 1917:
KIDWELLY GHOST LAID? PENRHIWCEIBER SPIRITUALISTS' CLAIM.
Some inhabitants of Penrhiwceiber, who are members of the Miskin Spiritualistic Society, visited Kidwelly Tuesday, the 13th inst., for the purpose of solving the ghost mystery. Their names are: Mr. and Mrs. Phillips, 2 Dillwyn Street, and Mr. and Mrs. Brabon, of 26 Dillwyn Street. They claim that they have effectually laid the ghost. They informed our Penrhiwceiber correspondent that they and seven prominent residents of Kidwelly assembled at the Gasworks house, which was "haunted." "We had just taken our seats," they added, "when our spirit friend started knocking." We may say that it is believed that it was the spirit of a working-man who was killed by an express on the line at Kidwelly some time ago.
Afterwards, the medium, Mrs. Brabon, allowed her spirit-guide to work, and for two hours was under cross-examination. The most important questions asked were:-
Can you tell me who is troubling this room? -Guide: Yes, I will show you. -Then the form of a man who was recognised by the assembly as the man who was killed by the express was shown.
If that is he tell me how he died? -Guide: By being killed.
Is there anyone in this room that knows this man? -Yes (pointing to the station- master), that gentleman used to pay him his wages.
It was alleged that further particulars were given which tallied with the facts of the accident in question, and were verified by the man who picked up the mutilated body on the line. —-At the close of the meeting Mr. Phillips asked all present if they were satisfied that it was the spirit of the man who was killed. They answered that all that the Guide had spoken was perfectly true, and they promised to take the spirit with them, so that it would not worry the house at the Gasworks any more.
So far no more knocking has been heard, it is said Mr. and Mrs. Brabon are prepared to answer any questions with regard to this report privately or publicly.
February 26th 1917, Cambria Daily Leader:
KIDWELLY SPOOK. SOME CURIOUS STORIES OF MESSAGES (By AWSTIN).
When you are in quest of "it," you should not be frivolous, and yet the heading of my previous article might have suggested to some that I was then writing in a very light mood. Fancy writing "ghosty" as an appellation for a spook. Now, that bit of flightineas must bo attributed to the "Printer's Devil," who (notwithstanding the introduction of type-setting machinery, still hovers around a printing office when the men are not in "chapel.") He must have been "it" in regard to that extra "y."
Among the curious stories I heard in confirmation and expansion of tho explanations given me by Mr. Rippin was one which showed that although the warning of the alleged spook on the question of vacating the house was not acted upon in ten days, no consequences followed but then, the warning was only a response to a question put, and the penalty (if any) was not mentioned. And the letter from Mr. J. Arthur Hill, on behalf of Sir Oliver Lodge, indicated that he does not think that such messages are always reliable. The period fixed has gone by, and nothing has happened!
On the other hand, communications with regard to distant friends (at the front) were correct, and further developments may yet bo anticipated in that, direction. The sequel does not depend upon the spook, but upon letters of friends. Stories of hidden money, and the possibility of search for it, must be taken with a grain of salt, as they do not emanate from the spook or the people in the house.
On the table in the middle of the room in which the taps are generally heard is a large family Bible, and, one night, a visitor placed his hand upon it. "It" was asked if it could see the gentleman. Three knocks came for yes. What has he got in his hand was next asked, and the answer was "a ring", but when further pressed about a book, the spirit, or whatever it is, replied, "The Holy Scriptures". On another occasion a new book on psychical subjects was held in the hand, and the presence gave the title of the book correctly. The stories are cited in support of the theory that "it" can not only hear what is said in the room, but see who and what is there.
Now, do not let us have any mistake about the character of these responses. They were not spoken in words. The spook's voice was not heard. The words were spelt out by the code referred to in Mr. Hill's letter." The person who asked the question would S: A," B," C," and follow on with the alphabet until he or she came to the right and proper one, when a tap from it would stop the querist going any further. And if an enthusiastic investigator proceeded with the alphabet too far, the spook would give several raps, or thumps, or dull thuds - you don't know exactly how to describe them and you don't know where they come from, whether from floor or ceiling or walls or furniture. When you have fixed one letter you begin on the alphabet again and go on until you get the second, and so on.
The story of the spoken voice is a separate one. When the ladv medium from Penrhiwceiber got into "control" of "it," some of the seekers after truth thought they might get her to elicit replies in good English or sound Welsh —in spoken words, so that they might hear the voice. The lady, however, explained that someone on a higher plane in the spirit world might be able to draw out the voice, but she could not. Now, as this is a story which has led to suggestions, among the gossips, of money transactions, it may be well to give the version of the incident which was related to me bv Mr. Rippin and absolutely confirmed by a gentleman who holds an important offical position in Kidwelly.
The lady medium said that she knew of a frignd who could probably do what was asked, but, as she was a professional, it would cost about £5 to get her to come. She did not advise getting her (as has been suggested), but in the peculiar intonation and "Mahatma"—like phrasing of one in a trance she defined her own limitations and seemingly the only way out of the difficulty, if such a solution was necessary. Nobody proposed spending £5 on the quest in that direction, and the matter dropped.
The quaint story of the cigarettes, take it any wy you like, is a decidedly funny one, but it requires telling carefully, as there are at least two versions of it. A well-known local man of business suggested that the "spook" might be asked if it remembered him giving "it," in its lifetime on earth, a box of 50 cigarettes. Mr. Rippin put the question, and the reply was "No." The "spirit" at what ever "it" is remembered tho gentleman very well, and could see him there, but it had not had 50 cigarettes from him —nor any cigarettes at all, in fact. No amount of pressure would get an admission from it," and at last Mr. Rippen gave up the attempt. Someone else in the room tried, and, after some fencing as to not remembering, the spirit admitted having had a parcel or packet, and it then misspelt the word cigarettes, fixing the number the packet contained at 50.
Mr. Rippin was very emphatic, in conversation with me, that he had not elicited that reply. It was brought out by another investigator, and as the gentleman who had desired the question to be put afterwards declared it was not true, as he had never given the original of the supposed spirit any cigarettes in his life, the incident has caused some unpleasantness in the little circle of inquirers, and investigators, owing mainly to the story having gone out in a form which seemed to suggest that Mr. Rippin got the spirit to tell a fib under pressure. But he did not.
And the answer to the success of such transparent traps, no doubt, would be the same as that of Mr. J. Arthur Hill (on the house vacating question): "I do not think such messages are always reliable." These stories, from grave to gay, from lively to serene, might be multiplied galore, but I think sufficient has been given to illustrate the character of the proceedings of spook and people at the Kidwelly haunted house. No solution of the mystery has yet been found, and the readiness and freedom with which those who have been present as watchers discuss "it" and its rapping have helped to make the Kidwelly "ghost" a household word in the town and for many, many miles around.
Not only have as many as 17 people been keenly watching together in one room, but small parties have sounded walls, floors, and ceilings, visited the children's bedrooms, and sometimes thought (wrongly, as it turned out) that they had discovered how the mystery was worked, but silent sentries, posted outside the house, in the gasworks yard, kept watch and ward, at the same time, lest confederates might be operating in the open air or from secret hidden places. However, there were no discoveries. There, for the present, I conclude my plain, unvarnished tale of the quest for "it" at Kidwelly. If there are further developments there may be something more to say—later on.
On March 2nd, the Carmarthen Journal reported:
THE KIDWELLY GHOST. The knockings of the Kidwelly ghost are getting louder, and the "spirit" has added to its achievements that of throwing the furniture about. On Wednesday night of last week a chair and a dress basket were hurled by some unseen force right across one of the bedrooms. On Friday night a small committee of investigators visited the house.
March 3rd 1917, Aberdare Leader:
Letters to the Editor. THE KIDWELLY GHOST. Re. the invitation to questions by Mr. and Mrs. Brabon concerning the report on the above subject, which appeared in your last issue, I should like to ask:- How do they explain the report that appeared in the press last Friday which says that the Kidwelly Ghost has become more aggressive than ever, making things unpleasant, and that it is still at the Gasworks House? Do they still maintain that they have removed the Ghost?
If so, was there any oversight or neglect on the part of the Ghost's custodians since they promised to take the Ghost with them? Now, with all the seriousness at my command, I beg to ask, Do they wilfully endeavour to deceive the public or are they themselves deceived? I am inclined to believe the latter, in which case they are more to be pitied than blamed.
—Yours, G. H. EVANS. 47 Dilwyn Street, Penrhiwceiber.
Aberdare Leader, March 10th 1917:
THE KIDWELLY GHOST.
Sir, Kindly allow me a small space in your paper to answer Mr. G. H. Evans's enquiries re the Kidwelly Ghost. Firstly, about the ghost becoming aggressive, I beg leave to contradict the statement appearing in the press. I have in my possession a letter from the tenant of tha haunted house to prove differently, and anyone calling at our house may see it. I think the lady is competent to judge.
Secondly, whether we maintain that we removed the ghost. We maintain that we proved to them who troubled the house, and that I would endeavour to help that friend to progress. Now to the third question, are we wilfully endeavouring to deceive the public or are we ourselves deceived? If so, I beg to say we are quite willing to be classed as lunatics in company with such highly scientific men as General Sir Alfred Turner, Sir Oliver Lodge, Sir Wm. Crookes, Stainton Moses, and others who firmly believe in the continuity of life and the power of communication with beings who have passed the border. And, Mr. Editor, I don't think we need the pity G. H. Evans expresses, because ordinary minds usually condemn everything that is beyond their scope of understanding.
We remain, T. & A. BRABON. 26 Dilwyn Street, Penrhiwceiber.
The last newspaper hit I found was from the Aberdare Leader of March 17th:
THE KIDWELLY GHOST. In your last issue there was a letter signed "T. and A. Brabon," upon the above subject, claiming to answer my query. If they were responsible for the letter that appeared as challenge they must know that the two statements are conflicting.
In that letter it says that they promised to take the ghost with them. In the last letter they say "that they proved who troubled the house." Between these there exists a vast difference. They further claim that the house is not still haunted. There appeared in the press several days after their departure from Kidwelly reports that it was still troubling. Why not refuse the press statements then, not now? Can they suggest why was a patrol placed around the house after they had claimed to have removed the ghost?
In the account of their visit we find that a certain Mr. Rippin put a question concerning a packet of 50 cigarettes. The ghost could not remember receiving any cigarettes from Mr. Rippin. Another again put the same question, and the answer came yes. Now, Mr. Rippin says he never did give the ghost any cigarettes. Now, an ordinary mind knows that what is contrary to the truth must be a lie.
They say they are willing to be classed as lunatics in company with certain men. Anyone knowing the meaning of the word lunatic would not apply it in such a case. There is not much fear of lunatics deceiving anybody. Since these people claim the company of such noted men, will they also include the women clairvoyants in Newport and London who have been punished for their practices!
Speaking of "ordinary mind", there are two classes outside the ordinary mind, i.e., above and below, but the ordinary mind is the ballast in the mental world. The extraordinary minds are very liable to go astray. Concerning the pity, I admit they ought to know best whether they deserve it or not.
—I am, yours, etc, G. H. EVANS. 47 Dilwyn Street, Penrhiwceiber.
